The Taming of Tech Criticism • ©[thebaffler.com]

What does it mean to be a technology critic in today’s America? And what can technology criticism accomplish? The first question seems easy: to be a technology critic in America now is to oppose that bastion of vulgar disruption, Silicon Valley. By itself, however, this opposition says nothing about the critic’s politics—an omission that makes it all the more difficult to answer the second question.

Why all the political diffidence? A critical or oppositional attitude toward Silicon Valley is no guarantee of the critic’s progressive agenda; modern technology criticism, going back to its roots in Germany at the turn of the twentieth century, has often embraced conservative causes. It also doesn’t help that technology critics, for the most part, make a point of shunning political categories. Instead of the usual left/right distinction, they are more comfortable with the humanist/anti-humanist one. “What if the cost of machines that think is people who don’t?”—a clever rhetorical question posed by the technology author George Dyson a few years ago—nicely captures these sorts of concerns. The “machines” in question are typically reduced to mere embodiments of absurd, dehumanizing ideas that hijack the minds of poorly educated technologists; the “humans,” in turn, are treated as abstract, ahistorical émigrés to the global village, rather than citizen-subjects of the neoliberal empire.

via The Taming of Tech Criticism – The Baffler.

Advertisements

Tags: ,

About plerudulier

Primarily interested in interacting and engaging with people about issues related to profession but also charity, environment, ... you get the idea.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

demontvalon1 le blog

Blog de Dominique de Montvalon, journaliste-éditorialiste politique

Invention - Europe

Le portail des inventeurs, des inventions et des innovations en Europe, propose des services gratuits pour aider les inventeurs à développer leurs inventions sur le Web. Ce site communautaire pour les inventeurs existe depuis avril 2001. Invention - Europe est le N°1 des sites francophones, sur le thème de l'invention. Fondé par Peter TEMEY, il est géré par l'association "Club Invention - Europe". Le site Invention - Europe est indépendant et refuse toute publicité payante.

BINAKUKO

Biso Na Bino ! Tous ensemble !

Les mille et une facettes

Sports, droit, médias, musiques, cinéma et remise en forme, voici le blog que tu dois voir !

Simplify Tasks

Want to learn the simple way?

Mademoiselle Maeve

Mademoiselle Maeve lit des livres

Bill Wirtz

Freelance journalist - Writer for a free society

Le magazine en ligne de la Fondation littéraire Fleur de Lys

Nouvelles, chroniques, dossiers, revue de presse,...

Urban Food Futures

The first online science magazine dedicated to sustainable urban food systems

Média des innovations agricoles

Partager les agricultures de demain

NicoChagny.net

Blog de veille de Nicolas CHAGNY /// DGA Data&Digital Services @ Makheia /// Président @ Internet Society France

Télégraphe 78

Télégraphe 78 : Pour mieux connaître la Vie Numérique du Sud-Yvelines !

Macademise

How to do your research on a mac.

Miss Marks Blogs

Teaching outside of my comfort zone

Java and Junket

Conversations about coffee, travel, and getting the most out of life

Paul's Project Server and Project Online Blog

Microsoft Project Server and Project Online (PPM)

Steve Goodyear

The SharePoint Whisperer's Notes & Ideas

%d bloggers like this: